For many, the word “circus” evokes imagery of popcorn, candy,
"wild" animals, and fun. However, behind the glitter and the glitz
of the circus lies a cruel world of untold animal suffering. Animals used
in circuses are unwilling participants in a show that jeopardizes their
health and mental well-being and the lives of human spectators and performers.
Trained by pain
Circuses force animals to perform tricks that have nothing to do with
how these magnificent creatures behave in the wild. These unnatural acts
range from a tiger jumping through a flaming hoop to bears riding bicycles.
Animals are sometimes injured while performing: tigers, who naturally
fear fire, have been burned jumping through flaming hoops. Training animals
to perform acts that are sometimes painful or that they do not understand
requires whips, tight collars, muzzles, electric prods and other tools.
Elephants are trained through the use of an ankus—a wooden stick
with a sharp, pointed hook at the end to discourage undesired behavior.
An elephant handler will never be seen working with an elephant without
an ankus in one hand or discreetly tucked under his arm. Although an elephant’s
skin is thick, it is very sensitive—sensitive enough to feel a fly
on her back. The ankus is embedded into elephants' most sensitive areas,
such as around the feet, behind the ears, under the chin, inside the mouth,
and other locations around the face. Sometimes it is used to smash them
across the face. Circuses claim to use "positive reinforcement"
and to base their tricks on behaviors that animals carry out naturally.
If this were true, however, the trainers would be carrying bags of food
treats, not a metal weapon.
Travel can be torture
Animals in circuses either travel in 18-wheelers or by train. During transport
and between performances, tigers, who in the wild would secure 75-2,000
square miles, are kept in cages with barely enough room to turn around.
Elephants, who walk up to 25 miles a day with their families in their
natural habitat, are shackled in chains by their front and back legs so
that they can't take a step forward or backward. They are forced to eat,
sleep, and defecate in the same trailers, where they can be kept for stretches
of more than 24 hours. Often the animals are not let off the railroad
cars immediately upon arrival in their destination, either because of
traffic conditions or because the train arrived too early or late. In
this instance, the animals are forced to wait inside of the railroad cars
for hours—even in extreme temperatures.
Circus schedules are created to maximize attendees, not to accommodate
the animals from which they profit. Some of the many U.S. circuses that
use animals travel as many as 48 weeks out of the year and cover thousands
of miles. Some circuses go to warmer states in the summer, even though
the animals may suffer in extreme temperatures. The same unfortunate situation
occurs in the winter in colder areas. These factors exacerbate the already
stressful conditions caused by confinement and transport.
Life in captivity
Even if conditions were improved and humane methods of training were used,
the fact is that keeping wild animals in captivity deprives animals of
much of what they value in life. Elephants, tigers, chimpanzees, and other
animals used in circuses are complex creatures—not robots to be
stacked in boxes and hauled to the next show. Animals have relationships
with other members of their species and would naturally live in social
groups or families. Baby elephants generally stay with their mothers for
fifteen years if they are male and their entire lives if they are female.
Yet in circuses, baby elephants are ripped from their mothers' sides as
young as one year old because baby elephants are cute and draw a crowd
which in turn helps the circus reap profit. Animals value exploring their
environment, nurturing their young, courting and mating, and playing with
others. However, in captivity, they are prevented from doing all of these
things and instead live a life based on human wants and whims.
Lives of constant confinement and frustration of natural instincts force
animals into a state of neurosis. Elephants in circuses constantly sway
back and forth in their chains, and tigers constantly pace in their cages.
These repetitive behaviors are symptoms of deep psychological distress
due to being deprived of fulfilling their natural instincts. Animals can
resort to self-mutilation from lack of psychological stimulation. These
animals belong in their natural environments in the jungles of Africa
and Asia—not in American arenas and parking lots.
Anti-Educational
Contrary to what circuses say and the justification some schools use for
taking students to circuses, seeing animals in circuses does not provide
a realistic educational tool because the animals are forced to perform
tricks and live in conditions that are not natural for them. The animals
are in an environment drastically different from their natural habitats,
and their spirits are broken from harsh training and from not being able
to fulfill some of their most basic needs and instincts.
Public safety: Reason for concern
Animals in circuses are a threat to public safety. When animals are brought
into a new town by train, they are often walked from the train to an arena
where they will be performing. Wild animals on city streets should give
communities reason to be concerned. Cars, pedestrians, and elephants are
side by side on busy city streets. Although some animals are accustomed
to the heat, they are not used to walking on hot pavement or to not having
access to water, trees, or mud holes. Circus trainers will even withhold
food and water from animals to reduce untimely excrement. Elephants are
harried along, forbidden to drink from puddles or snatch a branch from
a tree by a bullhook-wielding trainer. Having these instincts stifled
adds to the stress of transport and an unnatural environment, and animals
are much more likely to become violent under these conditions.
Elephants in circuses have gone on rampages, injuring and killing spectators
and causing property damage. Since 1990, 18 people have been killed and
86 have been injured. In 1994 an elephant named Tyke killed her handler,
then went on a rampage in the streets of Honolulu, injuring onlookers
and damaging property. Tyke was eventually gunned down by police on a
busy street. Other incidents have occurred when elephants are frightened,
sometimes by the honking of car horns or other stressors. Tigers have
also been known to attack and kill their trainers; others have escaped
into terrified communities.
Some elephants used in circuses have been found to carry a human strain
of tuberculosis (TB). These animals pose a serious health risk since they
are in contact with the public during publicity events and when children
receive elephant rides.
Fun circuses
An end to animal circuses doesn't mean an end to fun.
There are many circuses that are exciting and entertaining without abusing
animals. Cirque du Soleil, The New Pickle Family Circus, Circus Smirkus,
Cirque Eloize, Circus Oz and the Mexican National Circus are all wonderful
circuses that offer family entertainment using only willing human performers.
By supporting animal-free entertainment and boycotting circuses that
use animals, we can move towards an end to the use of animals in circuses.