Lucky_San Antonio Zoo

IDA Slams San Antonio Zoo On Solitary Elephant

April 25th, 2013 by Nicole Meyer


In Defense Of Animals Urges Zoo Agency To Deny One-Elephant Variance To San Antonio Zoo

San Antonio, Texas (April 25, 2013) – In Defense of Animals (IDA), an international animal protection organization, sent a letter today to the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA), urging the trade-industry organization to deny a variance request submitted by the San Antonio Zoo to maintain a solitary female elephant.

Zoo leaders announced this week their decision to keep an elephant named Lucky alone, following the death last month of a second elephant, Queenie. Now, the zoo is asking the AZA for a one-elephant variance, to support the zoo in depriving this profoundly social elephant of one of her most basic needs—the company of other elephants.

“We’re not surprised by the San Antonio Zoo’s cruel, selfish decision to keep Lucky as a solitary elephant,” said Nicole Meyer, Director of IDA’s Elephant Protection Campaign. “What is shocking is the blatant disregard for the welfare of this individual elephant. The decision to deny Lucky the opportunity to live her remaining years in the company of other elephants in a more suitable environment is driven by stubbornness and a complete lack of compassion on the part of the zoo’s leaders.”

This cycle of acquiring elephants, and requesting variances when one dies, appears to be an ongoing problem at the San Antonio Zoo, which has been sanctioned before by the AZA. The AZA issued the zoo a variance in 2008 after another elephant died, and again in 2009, but has stated it will not issue variances after 2016. The AZA has long recognized that female elephants should not be housed alone, suggesting that zoos hold a minimum of three female elephants.

“If the San Antonio Zoo refuses to do right by Lucky, the least the AZA can do now is step up to the plate and order the zoo to send Lucky to a facility that can meet her physical and social needs,” said Meyer. “The zoo’s claim that Lucky prefers to be alone is unfounded and a standard, misleading excuse. Elephants who have been similarly deprived of adequate companionship have bonded quickly with other elephants once they were moved to a more natural, spacious habitat and able to choose their own companions.”

The San Antonio Zoo has long been a focus of IDA for its grossly inadequate elephant exhibit and for cramming Earth’s largest land mammals into a space smaller than many backyards, creating an unhealthy and dangerous situation. At a meager half acre, the exhibit has room for barely one elephant, much less two or more. The zoo has appeared on IDA’s annual list of Ten Worst Zoos for Elephants four times and remains on the Hall of Shame.

Read IDA’s letter to the AZA.

85 Responses to “IDA Slams San Antonio Zoo On Solitary Elephant”

  1. April 26, 2013 at 6:49 am, anna said:

    E’ da nazisti comportarsi così !


  2. April 25, 2013 at 3:53 pm, jolanda kuzmanic said:

    Oh my God, what is wrong with these people. How would you like to live alone and have no one to be with . This is terrible. The picture I saw of the elephant looks like she is crying. PLEASE don’t let her be alone. Have a heart. Do the right thing. PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  3. April 25, 2013 at 1:09 pm, Michelle Hughes said:

    WTF is wrong with people!!! Time for a black ops mission to get her out of there. I’m down. Who’s with me. I’m serious. This is total BULLSHIT!! I hate ignorant selfish and stubborn people. I’d applaud Lucky for going on a rampage and killing the very people making her suffer!!!!


  4. April 25, 2013 at 12:19 pm, Sharon CohenSharon said:

    Poor Lucky has been suffering for 51 years of her life. The San Antonio Zoo is, and has been for a long time, to be considered one of the top 10 worst zoos in the country. The Director of this zoo is truly just being stubborn and cruel, and poor Lucky is being held captive by this sorry excuse of a human being.


  5. April 25, 2013 at 11:19 am, said:

    Here’s a suggestion for the San Antonio Zoo. Build a life size robotic elephant. Charge a dollar to push a button and hear it bellow. The kids will love it, just like they do the giant robotic dinasaur at the Oregon Zoo. The zoo will make money and it can retire Lucky to a sanctuary where she can finally have the freedom to roam and enjoy the remaining days of her life, not as an object of entertainment, but as a living, breathing sentient being who craves the company of her own species.


  6. April 25, 2013 at 11:14 am, Tamara Palmer said:

    Am so sorry to hear of Queenie’s passing, before she could enjoy a sanctuary


Leave a Reply