SEARCY, Ark. (Jan. 27, 2026) — In Defense of Animals decries the shocking failure of justice in the case of Franklin Scott Smith. Despite facing a felony animal cruelty charge after a stray dog was sadistically nailed to a board, Smith was acquitted of the cruelty charge and sentenced only for disorderly conduct.

On January 8, Judge Mark Pate sentenced Smith to 30 days in county jail for a disorderly conduct charge. He was acquitted of the Class D felony aggravated cruelty charge, and a public display of obscenity charge was dismissed.

The charges, filed by the White County Sheriff’s Department on March 6, 2024, stemmed from a horrific incident in November 2023. It is alleged that Smith shot and wounded the homeless dog, then nailed him to a plywood board spray painted to read, “THIS WHAT HAPPENS TO DOG DROP HERE.” Attached to this board was another, sprayed with the words “STOP DROP DOG.”

Evidence presented, including a necropsy, determined the gunshot wounds were not lethal. The massive blood loss on the board suggested the dog was sadistically tortured and likely alive when spikes were driven through his feet. Smith claimed he painlessly killed the dog for showing aggression to his family and animals.

In Defense of Animals had submitted a letter to District Prosecutor Rebecca Reed McCoy signed by 14,336 advocates, demanding Smith be convicted and handed the six-year maximum sentence for a Class D felony, a $10,000 fine, and mandatory psychiatric evaluation. The letter was intended to be presented to the presiding judge during the sentencing phase of his trial.

“Smith’s sadistically violent killing of an innocent dog who strayed near his property displays his psychotic tendency to inflict harm on anyone who angers him. Statistics have long supported the fact that the ‘Cycle of Violence’ doesn’t differentiate between victims. Perpetrators of violence must be dealt with in both the criminal and mental health systems to protect all members of society,” stated Doll Stanley, Senior Campaigner for In Defense of Animals.

### NOTES ###

Contact: Doll Stanley, doll@idausa.org, (662) 809-4483

Image (graphic): https://bit.ly/FranklinScottSmith 

In Defense of Animals is an international animal protection organization with over 250,000 supporters and a history of defending animals, people, and the environment through education and campaigns, as well as hands-on rescue facilities in India, South Korea, California, and rural Mississippi since 1983. www.idausa.org/justice4animals

###ENDS###